by Josh » January 16th, 2007, 12:57 pm
My affection and tendency toward presuppositional (contra classical) apologetics would lead me toward a third frame to the cartoon, possibly with the following quote in the cloud:
"Materialism isn't dead! It's coming back to life again in a new form, just as it did after the apparent deaths of Epicureanism, Enlightenment-era naturalism, and existentialism. This must be so because it is certain that the universe must be a closed, deterministic system based on random, sequential causation. Of course, it is a random chain of causation that leads me to reach such a conclusion and true truth is just an illusion. I nevertheless base my belief in the "truth" of materialism on faith, which, of course, is more virtuous than actual evidence when it suits my ends, which, of course, are more noble than those of religion because they are the unbiased ends of science. Of course, my materialism also prevent things like bias and nobility from having any real meaning. But that's not important. What is important is that religionists are deluded, although calling a thing a delusion implies the existence of truth, which my materialism tells me does not exist. In fact, my materialism, taken to its logical ends with all hint of faith removed, would lead me to the untrue truth that I don't exist. Is Starbucks open after 11?"
Was it Francis Bacon would said that a little philosophy leads one to atheism, while much philosophy leads one to religion?
ecclesia semper reformata, semper reformanda.
--John Calvin