Page 1 of 1

Surprised by Lewis

PostPosted: March 15th, 2010, 10:40 pm
by Sven

Re: Surprised by Lewis

PostPosted: March 16th, 2010, 7:44 pm
by Sven
I just finished the sequel, Escape from Hell, and it has even more Lewis in it. For starters, it's dedicated to him: "To C. S. 'Jack' Lewis". Then, a sizable part of the first few chapters is taken up with a conversation between the narrator and the shade of Sylvia Plath in the Wood of Suicides, during which Plath discusses Lewis and his thinking quite a bit.

Re: Surprised by Lewis

PostPosted: March 16th, 2010, 8:37 pm
by cyranorox
Sequel??? whoo hoo. Loved Inferno, never knew there was a sequel. And with Plath! going to get it forthwith.

Re: Surprised by Lewis

PostPosted: March 18th, 2010, 5:14 pm
by Nerd42
I must get this

Re: Surprised by Lewis

PostPosted: March 18th, 2010, 9:53 pm
by Nerd42
I am listening to the unabridged audiobook of Inferno now. Best line so far: "It's been Hell here since Dante published that book."

It's a very entertaining book, but I think it's depiction of Hell is terribly cartoonish and am disappointed that it takes more influence from Dante than from Lewis.

(later edit) Finished Inferno last night, listening to Escape from Hell now

(later later edit) These books annoy me. They seem to totally disregard Lewis's radically different imagery about hell and instead try to set our ideas of justice back to those of the 14th century. (Yes, I know Lewis was a classicist, but this is going way too far) It seems to bring up all the problems about hell again when The Great Divorce has already dealt with them so spectacularly and totally ignores the progress that was made on the issue in that book, while at the same time giving it lip service. I was hoping to find an updated Great Divorce but have instead discovered a horror novel that tries to drag The Great Divorce back down to the level of Dante. Lewis was certainly influenced by Dante but took it in a whole different direction, which I think was much closer to the right way, but these guys seem to be trying to bend it back again, which I find frustrating. But I'm only halfway through Escape from Hell at this point so they may fix it in the end. Still, very entertaining books full of interesting characters. It has all the famous bad people you didn't get to meet in The Great Divorce because they either hadn't died yet or else because Lewis was trying to avoid naming names. It needs Hitler though ... the lack of a Hitler cameo stinks throughout the plot.

I think the thing that really frustrates me about it is that we've established in The Great Divorce that hell needs no external punishments because the people in it make themselves miserable and the doors are locked from the inside. But with the imagery in these books, the people there could easily be there for eons by someone else's cruelty despite wanting to get out. The feeling one gets from these books is that all the people in Hell could easily end up in some random bad place for something they didn't even do. It's cartoonish and doesn't make sense. This seems like a very sloppy job in many places.

Re: Surprised by Lewis

PostPosted: March 26th, 2010, 1:39 am
by Nerd42
Ah, SPOILER ALERT Reading these books was like watching Dawn of the Dead and Day of the Dead back-to-back. I don't recommend them if you want Lewis-style stuff ... I'd recommend the "Journeys to Fayrah" series by Bill Myers if you want a C. S. Lewis style story.