by larry gilman » May 14th, 2005, 9:09 pm
I'm definitely being sarcastic, or rather humorous---"sarcasm" implies a snarling edge that I didn't intend---about the sunglasses and the Led Zeppelin. But the joke was reality-based: I have met a few conservative Christians who reacted with shock to the concept of listening to Led Zeppelin. Eek, a blues lyric! And one or two who believed that rock music does contain satanic code for the corruption of youth. The Led, by the way, were huge fans of Lewis's friend Tolkien, so there's another (roundabout) Lewis connection.
But just to be clear, since you don't ask specifically what I was or wasn't being sarcastic about, I was not being sarcastic about the list of un-Pat-Robertsonesque Lewis characteristics. All items on that list are literally accurate and unexaggerated, and can be proved by direct quotation from CSL. Not that I deny that Lewis was on the whole what we would call a "conservative," but it is also a fact that that term accepted different valences in England during Lewis's lifetime than it usually does in the USA today. And some of those valences, in Lewis's case, definitely bust the penguin-suit buttons. I mentioned some of them. I should perhaps have added to the list that his favorite Christian thinker, George MacDonald, the man Lewis called "my master," was a Universalist (though Lewis himself wasn't).
Best regards,
Larry