Firstly, it's not the only banned topic on Narniaweb.
Secondly, the suggestion that Ms Rowling's choice to reincarnate one of her evil characters in any way justifies speculation that Mr Lewis would do the same..... leaves me cold. There's no logic in it. The woman is famous for having a university degree or two, reading literature of several countries and writing derivative, self-indulgent children's literature suitable for teenagers but peddled to small children.
C.S.Lewis on the other hand, TAUGHT university students, read centuries of literature from several countries, and wrote literature for children and adults with a deliberately Christian message. They are not in the same ocean, not to mention being very different sized fish.
