Finally, after a long hiatus, I am back. Enjoy.
In this chapter Syme and his companions, Doctor Bull and the Professor, have come to a café were the Marquis St. Eustache is busy dining with some acquaintainces. Syme prepares a list of questions and replies for him and adversary; he comments that some of the Marquis' replies are quite witty and is drunk enough not to feel dishearted when its pointed out that his system is absurd. He walks over and attempts to pull his adversary's nose in order to strike up a duell with him. He doesn't succeed in pulling the Marquis' nose but succeeds in setting a duel for the next morning shortly before the train to Paris would depart. It is Syme's plan to delay the Marquis long enough to get him to get him to miss the train.
The next morning they meet at a field not far from the train station. The Professor and Bull are Syme's seconds and the Marquis' friends are his, the one a colonel in the French Légion d'honneur. The fight begins and Syme realizes that his oponent is a fierce warrior. But he manages to cut the Marquis in the face, only to see no wound. For the next few minutes he attempt to wound him in the face, but each wound gives no blood or cuts. This makes Syme panic somewhat more.
Finally when the train steams into the station does the Marquis surrender and offers Syme to pull his nose. His nose comes off and the Marquis begins to shed his face like a skin, saying that the train has caught him. Bull and Syme assert that they will not allow him to board the train, but the former Marquis says that indeed he is also a policeman (an inspector Radcliffe) and that they have played into a fiendish plot concocted by Sunday, who may have already taken the world while they were fighting in the field, and that Sunday or his Secretary were on the train to catch them. Seeing an army of masked men (one with the smile of the secretary) depart from the train they begin to run into the forrest. But that's for next time...
This is one of my favourite chapters, mostly because of its beginning (the part where Syme plans and confronts the Marquis) but also because it builds towards one of the sections of the book I like the most; the part where the earth temporarily descends into a state of anarchy as they believe that they are the last good men on the earth. The next two chapters I admire because they are so fraught with the elements of a nightmare; I wonder if Chesterton, knowing that his audience is bracing for the Secretary to be a policeman, decided to delay them with the elements of absurd anarchy. But I'm getting ahead of myself.
Interesting that when Syme gets up to confront the Marquis he gets up and hears a tune of music, similar like when he felt tempted to warn the police of the anarchist meeting a few chapters earlier. What force does this suggest? Growth of his intellectual and spiritual certainty?
Its strange that Inspector Ratcliffe is one of the few policemen in disguise (and indeed in deep cover) whose name we discover. It can be assumed that Doctor Bull remains Doctor Bull and Syme was always Syme, but we never learn the name of the Secretary, or of Gogol or the Professor. Of the Six Philosophers, only half of them are named. Oversight or hidden meaning? I vote for oversight. ;)