The witch's claim on Edmund

[Pete]

Perhaps the Witch had been learning of a way to destroy the Tree of Protection by her magic arts...

As to my reference to "the same time" of course I didn't mean literal same time or anything...but there is that implication (isn't there?) that when the Tree of Protection fell down it's daughter tree in London fell down. That's what I get out of the mention of the London tree blowing around when there wasn't any wind in London. Maybe the two trees had a similar relationship to each other as the dryad who goes to King Tirian had with her tree? Just a thought. ;)

[Erekose]

[Pete]

I don't mind becoming a heretic if that's the label given to one who theorizes. ;) After all...he didn't answer all those questions...why not think about different possibilities?

[Erekose]

Okay.. here's something to thing about...

Did any narnian ever find Edmunds torch?

When the wood of the Earth tree was used to make the wardrobe, what happened to the rest of the wood? (other raised possibilities.. a commemorative Railway Station Bench, a Picture Frame) Would Digory have just had it burnt.. what about carved figurines, pehaps depicting those he'd met when Narnia was created?

[Pete]

George, it sounds like you need to read Inside Narnia: A Guide to Exploring The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe by Devin Brown, he seems nearly as equally as heretical as you. Yes, I wonder about all this stuff....but usually I don't voice them...today's just different.

But anyway, Devin Brown, goes into the whole possibility of other (unaccounted) visits to Narnia, pointing out the picture from a friend of the Scrubb's house must have been given to them by someone who has been on a Narnian ship whose journey has been, as I said, unaccounted for. There's another of evidences Brown raises to support this...but I think those questions remain unanswered because the mystery is part of the strength of the Narnia series - especially in publication order! :)

[Erekose]

[Biff]

[Stanley Anderson]

[Erekose]

[Breka]

[Erekose]

Careful Breka, you may start turning into a Heretic.

Theres a large collection of my own Heresies buried down in the depths of the Chronicles Thread.. be wary of how deep you dig, lest you diturb the Ancient Evil.

If you wish to dare though...

And theres even more lurking around down there too